Starvation also happened in many other parts of the USSR, not only in Ukraine.
"In summary, we have established the following facts regarding the situation 1932–1933:
1 Natural drought played a role in creating the situation
2 Ex-landowning kulaks and Ukrainian nationalists did in fact refuse to work, murder collective workers, slaughter their own cattle, and otherwise actively sabotage the sowing and harvesting campaigns
3 Importing industrial machinery was the reason for exporting amounts of food in order to increase production as fast as possible
4 The cycle of famines which had existed for centuries prior and inherited by the Soviet authorities ended after the industrialization and collectivization policies had been fully implemented and the nazi invasion had ended
5 Under Stalin, the Ukrainization policy went into effect for over a decade before being changed due to rabid bourgeois Ukrainian nationalist elements exploiting it for treasonous activities
6 Stalin did not harbor any unique hostility to the Ukrainian nationalists anymore than he did the Russian nationalists who he fought in the civil war or even the Georgian nationalists who he fought in the August uprising
7 The Ukrainian nationalist movement in question was heavily tied to anti-semitism & fascistic beliefs before the 1930’s and exposed themselves in their true goals by aligning with nazi Germany in their hopes to create an ethno-state
8 Central Soviet Authorities sent hundreds of thousands of tonnes of food to the Ukrainians from other regions and Stalin himself personally intervened to scold a regional Russian official objecting to sending aid and made him send food
9 The situation of hunger encompassed the entire union to varying degrees, including impacting ethnic Russians
10 The situation in Ukraine during 1932–1933 was not intentional or man-made by Joseph Stalin or the Central Soviet Authorities
11 The overwhelming and vast majority of countries on this planet do not recognize this situation as being a “genocide”"
Thanks for great work.
Contradictory map about Holodomor:
https://www.lindelof.nu/han-som-tyckte-om-ryssarna-iii-karaktarsmordet/
According to that map:
Starvation was not happening in all of Ukraine.
Starvation also happened in many other parts of the USSR, not only in Ukraine.
"In summary, we have established the following facts regarding the situation 1932–1933:
1 Natural drought played a role in creating the situation
2 Ex-landowning kulaks and Ukrainian nationalists did in fact refuse to work, murder collective workers, slaughter their own cattle, and otherwise actively sabotage the sowing and harvesting campaigns
3 Importing industrial machinery was the reason for exporting amounts of food in order to increase production as fast as possible
4 The cycle of famines which had existed for centuries prior and inherited by the Soviet authorities ended after the industrialization and collectivization policies had been fully implemented and the nazi invasion had ended
5 Under Stalin, the Ukrainization policy went into effect for over a decade before being changed due to rabid bourgeois Ukrainian nationalist elements exploiting it for treasonous activities
6 Stalin did not harbor any unique hostility to the Ukrainian nationalists anymore than he did the Russian nationalists who he fought in the civil war or even the Georgian nationalists who he fought in the August uprising
7 The Ukrainian nationalist movement in question was heavily tied to anti-semitism & fascistic beliefs before the 1930’s and exposed themselves in their true goals by aligning with nazi Germany in their hopes to create an ethno-state
8 Central Soviet Authorities sent hundreds of thousands of tonnes of food to the Ukrainians from other regions and Stalin himself personally intervened to scold a regional Russian official objecting to sending aid and made him send food
9 The situation of hunger encompassed the entire union to varying degrees, including impacting ethnic Russians
10 The situation in Ukraine during 1932–1933 was not intentional or man-made by Joseph Stalin or the Central Soviet Authorities
11 The overwhelming and vast majority of countries on this planet do not recognize this situation as being a “genocide”"
Source: https://www.hamptonthink.org/read/stalin-in-ukraine-a-critical-examination-of-the-holodomor